| All-Great Northeast Athletic Conference | ECAC All-Star Team | |||||||||
| 2020 | Scott Sterenberg | OH | Sr. | Second Team | 2015 | Jeff Vautrin | OH | Jr. | First Team | |
| Jesus Garcia | S | Fr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Cobi Moore | L | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2019 | Jordan Aprea | OH/DS | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Andy Henriquez | S | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Jordan Aprea | OH/DS | Sr. | Defensive Player/Year | |||||||
| 2018 | Jordan Aprea | OH/DS | Jr. | Third Team | ||||||
| 2017 | Tristan Davis | OH/MB | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Patrick MacDonald | SR/S | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Jeff Vautrin | OH | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Jordan Aprea | L | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Janci Soto | MB | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||
| 2016 | Patrick MacDonald | RS | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Ryan Jackson | OH | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2015 | Jeff Vautrin | OH | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Dan Raffol | OH | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Tom Olson | Coach/Year | |||||||||
| 2014 | Dan Raffol | OH | Jr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Jeff Vautrin | OH | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2013 | Dan Raffol | OH | So. | Second Team | ||||||
| Alex Mill | OH | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2012 | Alex Mill | OH | Jr. | Third Team | ||||||
| 2011 | Mike Harrington | MH | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Andrew Glenn | S | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| Andrew Glenn | S | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||
| 2010 | Brendan McGourn | S | So. | First Team | ||||||
| Spencer Parker | OH | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| Micah Aiu | MH | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Dan Rogers | MH | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2009 | Brendan McGourn | S | Fr. | First Team | ||||||
| Dave Rogers | MH | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Brendan McGourn | S | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||