| All-Great Northeast Athletic Conference | ||||||||||
| 2022 | Tyler Rose | D | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Alex Beauchemin | GK | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| James Anderson | A | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| David Burke | M | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Brendan Johnson | M | GS | Second Team | |||||||
| Ethan Dallas | D | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Landon Reyes | A | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Steven Phelps | F/O | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Magnus Leonard | D | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Ryan Stone | A | Fr. |
All-Rookie Team |
|||||||
| Alex Beauchemin | GK | Sr. | Goalkeeper of the Year | |||||||
| Jordan Hines |
M | Sr. | All-Sportsmanship Team | |||||||
| USILA All-America | ||||||||||
| 2021 | Andrew Fidalgo | A | Sr. | First Team | 2019 | David Sheehan | D | Sr. | Hon. Mention | |
| Colby Buccheri | M | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Chase Kapuscienski | M | GS | First Team | ECAC All-New England | ||||||
| David Burke | SSM | Jr. | First Team | 2009 | Mike Maggio | M | Sr. | First Team | ||
| Ethan Bain | D | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Magnus Leonard | D | So. | First Team | 2008 | Mark DeMeiri | GK | Sr. | Second Team | ||
| Alex Beauchemin | GK | Jr. | First Team | |||||||
| Kyle Charlot | LSM | So. | Second Team | NEILA Senior All-Star Game | ||||||
| Steven Phelps | F/O | Jr. | Second Team | 2021 | Ethan Bain | D | ||||
| Tyler Rose | D | Jr. | Second Team | Colby-Buccheri | M | |||||
| Chase Kapuscienski | M | GS | Offensive Player/Year | Andrew Fidalgo | A | |||||
| Magnus Leonard | D | So. | Defensive Player/Year | |||||||
| Alex Beauchemin | GK | Jr. | Goalkeeper/Year | 2019 | Ryan Madden | M | ||||
| Bill Mason | Coach/Year | David Sheehan | D | |||||||
| Mike Susi | M | |||||||||
| 2019 | Ryan Madden | A | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| David Sheehan | D | Sr. | First Team | 2017 | Jorge Salazar | G | ||||
| Evan Abatelli | D | Sr. | First Team | Anthony Saitta | M | |||||
| Mike Susi | M | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Brendan Johnson | M | Jr. | First Team | 2016 | Mike Pino | D | ||||
| Andrew Fidalgo | A | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Colby Buccheri | M | So. | Second Team | 2010 | Brian Yepez | A | ||||
| Ben Werner | M | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Tyler Rose | D | So. | Second Team | 2009 | Mike Maggio | M | ||||
| Alex Beauchemin | GK | Fr. | Second Team | Matt Stambler | D | |||||
| James Anderson | A | Fr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Dan Gorman | M | Jr. | Third Team | 2008 | Mark DeMeiri | GK | ||||
| James Anderson | A | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||
| 2007 | Al Zayac | A | ||||||||
| 2018 | Austin Tomasetti | A | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Ryan Madden | M | Jr. | First Team | 2006 | Louis Lucchetti | M | ||||
| Greg Klaum | M | Sr. | First Team | Kyle Minaker | M | |||||
| David Sheehan | D | Jr. | First Team | |||||||
| Travis Duhamel | D | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Alex McCormack-Kuhman | M | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Matt Carnavale | M | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| Ben Werner | M | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2017 | Jorge Salazar | GK | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Ryan Madden | M | So. | First Team | |||||||
| Darien Clay | D | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| Connor Johnson | M | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Daniel Gorman | D | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| Josh Gallant | A | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Austin Tomasetti | A | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Alex McCormack-Kuhman | M | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| David Sheehan | D | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Anthony Saitta | M | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Jorge Salazar | GK | Sr. | Goalkeeper/Year | |||||||
| Daniel Gorman | D | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||
| Bill Mason | Coach/Year | |||||||||
| 2016 | Ryan Madden | M | Fr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Mike Pino | D | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Casey Sullivan | A | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Pat Egan | A | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Connor Johnson | M | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Austin Tomasetti | M | Third Team | ||||||||
| 2015 | Andrew Suh | A | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Aaron Laporte | M | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Mike Pino | D | Jr. | First Team | |||||||
| Casey Sullivan | A | Jr. | Second team | |||||||
| 2014 | Andrew Suh | A | So. | First Team | ||||||
| Casey Sullivan | A | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Joe Cunning | M | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Mike Pino | D | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2013 | Andy Puopolo | A | So. | First Team | ||||||
| Dylan Fernandes | M | So. | First Team | |||||||
| Atticus Robert | M | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Eric Marcantonio | D | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Matt Keiler | D | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2012 | Dylan Gray | A | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Eric Marcantonio | D | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| Adam Foss | M | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Pat Bresnahan | M | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Atticus Robert | M | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Don Berube | GK | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Dylan Gray | A | Jr. | Offensive Player/Year | |||||||
| 2011 | Dylan Gray | A | So. | First Team | ||||||
| Nick Sampson | M | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Adam Foss | M | Jr. | First Team | |||||||
| Chris Bulkley | M | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Matt Keiler | D | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Eric Walsh | GK | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Dylan Fernandes | M | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||
| All-Pilgrim League | ||||||||||
| 2010 | Chris Bulkley | M | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Brian Yepez | A | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Matt Keiler | D | Fr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Anthony Erz | D | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Rob Suh | D | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2009 | Mike Maggio | M | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Matt Stambler | D | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Brandon Keith | A | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2008 | Mike Maggio | M | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Matt Stambler | D | Jr. | First Team | |||||||
| Mark DeMeiri | GK | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Dave Bulhoes | A | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Alex Engels | M | Fr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2007 | Al Zayac | A | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Mike Maggio | M | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Mark DeMieri | GK | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2006 | Louis Lucchetti | M | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Kyle Minaker | M | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Al Zayac | A | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2005 | Louis Lucchetti | M | Jr. | |||||||
| Kyle Minaker | M | Jr. | ||||||||
| Mark DeMieri | GK | Fr. | ||||||||
| Tim Dunton | Coach/Year | |||||||||
| 2003 | Louis Lucchetti | M | So. | |||||||
| 2002 | Louis Lucchetti | M | Fr. | |||||||