| All-Great Northeast Athletic Conference | ||||
| 2021 | Ally Kirck | OF | Fr. | Second Team |
| Katie Hopkins | 3B | Fr. | Third Team | |
| Eryn Sheeley | P | Fr. | Third Team | |
| 2016 | Nicole LeBlanc | UTIL | Sr. | Second Team |
| 2014 | Nicole LeBlanc | C | So. | Third Team |
| Santina Antoshak | OF | Sr. | Third Team | |
| 2013 | Nicole LeBlanc | UTIL | Fr. | Third Team |
| 2012 | Talia DiChiara | INF | Sr. | Third Team |
| Alison Saluti | P | Jr. | ||
| 2010 | Ashley Laramie | INF | Jr. | Second Team |
| Kelly Barden | INF | Sr. | Second Team | |
| Rachelle Haas | OF | Fr. | Second Team | |
| 2009 | Ashley Laramie | DP | Fr. | First Team |
| Heather Lynch | C | Sr. | Third Team | |
| Heather Rose | INF | So. | Third Team | |
| Michelle Torres | OF | So. | Third Team | |
| Tricia Culver | OF | Jr. | Third Team | |
| 2008 | Tiffany Perla | OF | Jr. | Second Team |
| All-North Atlantic Conference | ||||
| 2007 | Jayme Rautenberg | C | Sr. | Player/ Year |
| Tom DeFilippo | Coach/Year | |||
| 2006 | Wendy Riddle | INF | Sr. | Second Team |
| 2005 | Jayme Rautenberg | C | Fr. | Rookie/year |
| 2003 | Britney Falite | First Team | ||
| Wendi DiFilippo | First Team | |||
| Jen Hiza | INF/C | Jr. | Second Team | |
| Sonja Landry | P/INF | Sr. | Second Team | |
| Britney Falite | Player/Year | |||
| 2002 | Britney Falite | |||
| Sonja Landry | P/INF | Jr. | ||
| Jen Hiza | INF/C | So. | ||
| Jen Hiza | Rookie/Year | |||
| 2001 | Wendi DiFilippo | Second Team | ||
| Britney Falite | Co-Player/Year | |||
| Sonja Landry | P/INF | So. | Rookie/Year | |