| All-Great Northeast Athletic Conference | NSCAA All-America | |||||||||
| 2015 | Miguel Colmenares | Sr. | GK | First Team | 2013 | Mike Skelton | Sr. | F | Third Team | |
| Conor Fitzgerald | Sr. | F | Third Team | |||||||
| Miguel Colmenares | Sr. | GK | Goalkeeper/Year | NSCAA All-New England | ||||||
| 2013 | Mike Skelton | Sr. | F | First Team | ||||||
| 2014 | Conor Fitzgerald | Jr. | F | First Team | Nery Guerra | Sr. | M | Second Team | ||
| Patrick McCarthy | Sr. | D | First Team | |||||||
| Newton Jordan | Fr. | M | Third Team | 2012 | Mike Skelton | Jr. | F | First Team | ||
| Eddie Roman | Sr. | M | Third Team | Nery Guerra | Jr. | M | Second Team | |||
| Newton Jordan | Fr. | M | Rookie of the Year | |||||||
| 2003 | Graig Murphy | Jr. | GK | First Team | ||||||
| 2013 | Mike Skelton | Sr. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Cedric Dybaud | Sr. | M | First Team | NEISL Senior All-Star Game | ||||||
| Nery Guerra | Jr. | M | Second Team | 2015 | Taylor Witherbee | |||||
| Manny Alves | Jr. | D | Second Team | |||||||
| Sokol Bako | Sr. | M | Third Team | 2010 | Paul Meucci | |||||
| Mike Skelton | Sr. | F | Offensive POY | |||||||
| 2009 | Zach Gagne | |||||||||
| 2012 | Mike Skelton | Jr. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Nery Guerra | Jr. | M | First Team | |||||||
| Adam Luciano | Sr. | D | Second Team | |||||||
| Miguel Colmenares | Fr. | GK | Third Team | |||||||
| Sokol Bako | Jr. | M | Third Team | |||||||
| Cedric Dybaud | Jr. | M | Third Team | |||||||
| Eric Fournier | Sr. | D | Third Team | |||||||
| Kyle Cronin | Sr. | F | Third Team | |||||||
| Mike Skelton | Jr. | F | Offensive POY | |||||||
| 2011 | Mike Skelton | So. | F | Second Team | ||||||
| Nery Guerra | So. | M | Second Team | |||||||
| Jon Klippert | Sr. | D | Third Team | |||||||
| 2010 | Dan Hatch | Sr. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Matthew Bruninghaus | Jr. | GK | First Team | |||||||
| Marcus Lopez | Fr. | M | Third Team | |||||||
| Sean Fisher | Sr. | D | Third Team | |||||||
| Dan Hatch | Sr. | F | Offensive/Year | |||||||
| 2009 | Dan Hatch | So. | F | First team | ||||||
| Paul Meucci | Sr. | D | First team | |||||||
| Kyle Cronin | So. | F | Second Team | |||||||
| Shane Vinnicombe | Sr. | M | Second Team | |||||||
| Mike Skelton | Fr. | M | Second Team | |||||||
| Brandon Hanss | Sr. | D | Second Team | |||||||
| Sean Fisher | Jr | D | Second Team | |||||||
| Julian Dutton | Sr. | GK | Second Team | |||||||
| Steve Petrin | Jr. | M | Third Team | |||||||
| 2008 | Zach Gagne | Sr. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Dan Hatch | So. | F | Third Team | |||||||
| Kuol Acuek | Sr. | M | Third Team | |||||||
| 2007 | Zach Gagne | Jr. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Brian Whelan | Sr. | M | Second Team | |||||||
| All-North Atlantic Conference | ||||||||||
| 2006 | Jeff Danso | So. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Julain Dutton | Fr. | GK | First Team | |||||||
| Zach Gagne | So. | F | First Team | |||||||
| Andy Roch | Sr. | M | First Team | |||||||
| Brian Whelan | Jr. | M | First Team | |||||||
| Giovanni Pacini | Coach of the Year | |||||||||
| 2005 | Andy Roch | Jr. | M | First Team | ||||||
| Mike Dewire | Sr. | D | Second Team | |||||||
| Zach Gagne | Fr. | F | Second Team | |||||||
| 2004 | Brian Whelan | So. | F | First Team | ||||||
| Matt Denham | Sr. | F | Second Team | |||||||
| Mike Petrucelli | Sr. | D | Second Team | |||||||
| Andy Roch | So. | M | Second Team | |||||||
| 2003 | Graig Murphy | Jr. | GK | First Team | ||||||
| Matt Denham | Jr. | F | First Team | |||||||
| Hayden Barbosa | Sr. | FB | First Team | |||||||
| Matt Walsh | Fr. | F | Second team | |||||||
| 2002 | Ronny Salmeron | Jr. | First Team | |||||||
| Anthony Scarsella | Sr. | First Team | ||||||||
| Graig Murphy | So. | GK | Second Team | |||||||
| Bryan Silviera | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||||
| 2001 | Eric Lewandowski | Sr. | FB | First Team | ||||||
| Steve Rochon | Fr. | First Team | ||||||||
| Steve Rochon | Fr. | Rookie of the Year | ||||||||
| Ronny Salmeron | So. | |||||||||
| 2000 | Eric Lewandowski | Jr. | FB | |||||||
| Dean Scarsella | So. | F | ||||||||
| Bryan Silviera | Jr. | M | Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Giovani Pacini | Coach of the Year | |||||||||
| 1999 | Anthony Scarsella | So. | F | |||||||
| Michael Carr | Fr. | M | Rookie of the Year | |||||||