| All-Great Northeast Athletic Conference | NEIBA All-New England | |||||||||
| 2021 | Charlie Danaher | 1B | Sr. | First Team | 2016 | Wes Hurty | C | Sr. | Third Team | |
| Darek Lallo | P | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| Matt Motyka | DH | Jr. | Second Team | 2012 | Conor Cavanagh | OF | Sr. | Third Team | ||
| Ross Audet | SS | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| Harrison Silva | OF | Sr. | Third Team | 2011 | Conor Cavanagh | OF | Jr. | Third Team | ||
| Joe Sullivan | C | GS | All-Defensive Team | |||||||
| ABCA All-New England | ||||||||||
| 2019 | David Marsell | P/2B | Sr. | First Team | 2016 | Wes Hurty | C | Sr. | Third Team | |
| Andre Marchesseault | 3B | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Joe Sullivan | C | Jr. | Second Team | D3Baseball.com All-New England | ||||||
| Evan Michalek | OF | Sr. | All-Defensive Team | 2017 | Hector Coscione | Util. | Sr. | Third Team | ||
| 2018 | Andre Marchesseault | 3B | Jr. | First Team | 2016 | Wes Hurty | C | Sr. | Second Team | |
| Sean Doris | OF | Fr. | First Team | |||||||
| David Marsell | P/2B | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2017 | Brandon Valentin | OF | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Hector Coscione | UP | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Dom Mascolo | 1B | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Andre Marchesseault | 3B | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| Skylar Beckerman | OF | Gr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2016 | Wes Hurty | C | Sr. | First Team | ||||||
| Dan Gagnon | INF | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Skylar Beckerman | OF | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Hector Coscione | INF/P | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Brett Sherron | 1B | Fr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Wes Hurty | C | Sr. | Player of Year/All-Defensive | |||||||
| 2015 | Aj McKenzie | 2B | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Wes Hurty | C | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Matt Sammarco | OF | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Tyler Flaherty | 3B | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Kevin Post | DH/P | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Greg Sherman | P | Sr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Josh Bahnick | P | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||
| 2014 | Billy Uberti | 1B | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Kevin Post | UP | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| Dan Gagnon | INF | So. | Second Team | |||||||
| Wes Hurty | C | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| Hector Coscione | INF | Fr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2013 | Bobby Stachura | 3B | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Billy Uberti | 1B | Jr. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2012 | Conor Cavanagh | OF | Sr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Josh Sullivan | 2B/P | Sr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2011 | Josh Sullivan | 2B | Jr. | First Team | ||||||
| Conor Cavanagh | OF | Sr. | First Team | |||||||
| Carlton Lentini | SS | Jr. | Second team | |||||||
| Josh Sullivan | P | Jr. | Second team | |||||||
| Eric Howard | P | Fr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Christopher Pittman | C/P | Fr. | Third Team | |||||||
| Bobby Stachura | 3B | So. | Third Team | |||||||
| 2010 | Josh Sullivan | P | So. | Second Team | ||||||
| Conor Cavanagh | OF | Jr. | Second Team | |||||||
| 2009 | Josh Sullivan | UP | Fr. | Second Team | ||||||
| Mike Mahoney | P | Fr. | Rookie/Year | |||||||